The Duke Lacrosse Case : The Story of Crystal Mangum

In March 2006, Crystal Mangum, a stripper, was hired to perform at a party organized by Duke University lacrosse players David Evans, Collin Finnerty, and Reade Seligmann. The party took place at 610 N. Buchanan Blvd., and Mangum was accompanied by another hired dancer.

According to Mangum, during the event she went to the bathroom and was then trapped by Evans, Finnerty, and Seligmann, who allegedly raped and sexually assaulted her. Mangum reported the incident to the police, and all three players were indicted on charges of rape, kidnapping, and sexual assault.

The allegations quickly garnered national media attention, and Duke University President Richard Brodhead suspended the lacrosse team’s upcoming games. Many criticized the media and university for rushing to judgment before charges were formally proven.

On March 30, DNA tests were conducted on samples taken from Mangum. None of the DNA found matched Evans, Finnerty, or Seligmann. Despite this, prosecutor Mike Nifong of Durham County continued with the case, relying heavily on Mangum’s testimony. On April 17, Nifong charged Seligmann and Finnerty with rape. On May 15, Evans was also charged.

All three men pleaded not guilty. As the court proceedings advanced, Nifong was accused of withholding crucial evidence. According to WRAL News:

“When DNA testing failed to find any evidence that any lacrosse player raped the accuser, Nifong told a reporter the players might have used a condom. Nifong knew that assertion was misleading because he had received a report from an emergency room nurse in which the accuser said her attackers did not use a condom.”

On April 11, 2007, North Carolina Attorney General Roy Cooper reviewed the case and concluded

“There is insufficient evidence to proceed on any of the charges.”

He publicly declared the three players innocent, citing significant inconsistencies in Mangum’s statements compared to the evidence.

Following the dismissal of charges, Evans’ attorney, Joseph Cheshire, commented:

“We felt sorry for her, and we felt, to some degree, she had been victimized by the process.”

Evans, Finnerty, and Seligmann, along with 38 other lacrosse players and their families, filed a lawsuit against Duke University for damages they suffered due to the false allegations. On June 18, 2007, Duke announced a private settlement with the three athletes for an undisclosed amount. The players issued a statement afterward:

“It is impossible to fully describe what we, our families, and team endured. As we said from day one, we are innocent. But it took 394 days and the intervention of the North Carolina Attorney General before our innocence was formally declared.”

The three men also filed a civil suit against the city of Durham, Mike Nifong, and others involved in the case. As part of the resolution, Durham agreed to a one-time grant of $50,000 to the North Carolina Innocence Inquiry Commission.

In the years that followed, Crystal Mangum published a memoir titled The Last Dance for Grace: The Crystal Mangum Story, co-authored with Vincent “Ed” Clark. In the book, she discusses her version of the Duke case, as well as a traumatic experience at age 14 when she was allegedly gang raped by an older boyfriend she referred to as “Fred.”

Mangum wrote:

“Even as I try to move on with my life, I still find it necessary to take one more stand and fight. I want to assert, without equivocation, that I was assaulted. Make of that what you will. You will decide what that means to you because the state of North Carolina saw fit not to look at all that happened the night I became infamous.”

She also stated:

“I’m not who they say I am. I’m not lying. Something did happen to me.”

According to Mangum, she was interviewed by CNN’s Soledad O’Brien for four hours, but the segment was never aired. She claims CNN never explained why.

Mangum and Clark said the book wasn’t written to re-ignite controversy, but to give her a voice. Clark defended her, saying:

“She is not evil, a drug abuser, or a criminal.”

Evans’ attorney Joseph Cheshire responded:

“My advice would be that if this book comes out and it contains things that are not true about what happened on that evening… she should not make one single penny off of it.”

On June 16, 2007, CNN reported that Mike Nifong lost his law license following a disciplinary hearing related to his handling of the case.

Years later, in a surprising development, Crystal Mangum recanted her accusations. In 2024, while serving an 11-year prison sentence for the second-degree murder of her ex-boyfriend, she gave an interview from jail with Katerina DePasquale on the show Let’s Talk with Kat. Mangum admitted:

“I testified falsely against them by saying that they raped me when they didn’t, and that was wrong. And I betrayed the trust of a lot of other people who believed in me.”

She added:

“I made up a story that wasn’t true because I wanted validation from people and not from God. I was looking for love and acceptance. People to love me, to pay attention to me. But you can get all of that in Jesus. He loves us just the way we are. That’s what I learned in prison. I hurt my brothers, and I hope they can forgive me. I love them, and they didn’t deserve that.”

The “brothers” she referred to were Evans, Finnerty, and Seligmann. As of now, the three men have not publicly responded to her statement.

If you would like to support my work consider leaving me a tip at Buymeacoffee. Much appreciated